Falling For My Alpha Stepsister (GL)
Chapter 45: Tasting The Pie

Chapter 45: Tasting The Pie

Finally, everything was over. The loud music faded, the last of the bouncy castles deflated with a long hiss, and the children returned to their hostel with the nuns. I stretched my aching back, feeling the heavy exhaustion settling right into my bones. Benny gave us a lift across the parking lot back to where Angel had parked her car, around my library.

"Are you sure you want me to leave you alone with her... don’t you want me to drive you home..?" Benny said after taking a long, cautious look at Angel, who had just entered her car, slamming the door shut and waiting for me to get in.

Benny’s fingers tapped nervously against her own steering wheel.

"Don’t trouble yourself too much, Benny.. we live in the same house, so there is no difference in who takes who home...." I said, giving her a reassuring smile and leaning against her window.

Benny hesitated for a second, her brows furrowed as she glanced over at Angel’s sleek black car sitting in the shadows. "Okay.. just be careful.."

"I will.."

"And thank you for tonight... looking forward to seeing each other this weekend.."

"Yes.. more like looking forward to seeing Sister Mary..." I teased, bumping my shoulder against her door frame.

Benny’s cheeks flushed a bright pink in the dim streetlights. She smiled sheepishly, stepping out of her car for a quick second, and then hugged me tightly, her arms wrapping around my shoulders.

"Goodnight, friend.." she murmured softly into my hair before pulling back.

"Goodnight, Benny."

I stood on the quiet pavement and watched Benny enter her car and drive off, her red taillights slowly fading down the dark empty road.

The silence of the night hit me all at once. I took a very deep breath, letting the cool night air fill my lungs before turning to Angel’s car.

I unlocked the passenger door and slid inside. I hadn’t even entered the car fully, just about to sit down and pull my fairy skirt inside when Angel’s sharp, sarcastic voice sliced through the quiet space.

"You should have just followed her home and continued hugging till eternity so it would be clear you both were just saying goodnight..." Angel snapped, her hands resting heavily on top of the leather steering wheel.

I pulled my seatbelt across my chest and clicked it into place, turning my head to look at her dark side profile.

"Oh, are you now jealous I was hugging someone who isn’t you?" I said, puffing my lips out and giving her a dramatic puppy face.

Angel scoffed loudly, turning her head toward me with a fierce glare.

"Stop making that face, it’s weird and makes your four eyes look bigger.... and why would I be jealous..? I don’t care about who you hug, it’s not my cup of tea if you hug some beta who has a fetish for nuns.."

I gasped, my eyes widening behind my round glasses.

"She is not a fetish for nuns, they just happen to be in love... they love each other.." I defended them, waving my hand around to emphasize my words.

Angel rolled her eyes so hard I thought they would roll out of her head.

"Oh lovie birds, my fucking balls... crap, bullshit.. that is not love... she just wants to taste the nun pie.. the next time I see her I will ask her how tasty the pie is, and if she gives me a positive review, also the recipe, I will try to have one myself.."

My face turned completely hot.

"You are a disgusting kind of person.."

Angel tilted her head, her lips twisting into a mean, taunting smirk.

"What, so it’s fine for her to eat the pie but disgusting for me to want to know how it tastes..?"

"Yes.. and no. Benny and Sister Mary are in love, so they can taste each other’s pie.."

The moment the words left my lips, I froze, my throat locking up instantly.

What in the world am I saying..

My cheeks were burning so hot I felt like crying.

Why is Angel making this conversation weird?

She should just drive and let’s go home so we can do what we want to do, and I have work tomorrow morning.

Angel leaned across the center console, her crimson eyes flashing in the dim light of the dashboard.

"I am not in love with you, and you let me eat your pie.. see, no love between us and we tasted each other..."

My head snapped toward her before my brain could stop my mouth.

"I haven’t tasted you..." I blurted out and swallowed my words, clapping both hands over my mouth immediately.

A massive, filthy grin spread across Angel’s face.

"Oh, oh, oh... look who is loosening up bit by bit.. I knew you loved our first night, you crave for it.. I may have failed in my intention to cripple your legs, but you are a bad slut for loving it.... hahaha.." She threw her head back and laughed, a loud, wicked sound that filled the small car.

This is bad, this is very bad.

My stomach plummeted straight into my shoes. I didn’t want Angel to know about that night because it would give her the ultimate satisfaction and a forever ticket to mocking me every single day for the rest of my life.

"I did not mean what I just said.. it was a slip of the tongue..." I stuttered frantically, pressing my back flat against the leather seat, trying to shrink away from her.

Angel leaned in closer, her voice dropping into a thick, husky murmur that sent a wild shiver down my spine.

"My tongue is available to slip... inside your cunt tonight... come on, don’t fight it, see the way you were looking at me today... You were thirsty, I could perceive your juicy cunt without even looking at you..."

I swallowed hard, my knuckles turning pale, trying to resist.

She leaned right against my ear, her hot breath brushing my skin as she whispered, "I know when you get wet and it’s all for me..."

My body betrayed me instantly, a sudden rush of heat pooling right between my thighs. My toes curled inside my flats.

"I wasn’t thinking of you when I got wet..." I whispered, my voice trembling badly.

"Liar, even right now you are wet..." Angel purred, shifting back into her seat with a triumphant look on her face.

Damn this, this must be because of the knot... bonding and everything.

My mind raced back to all those health lectures. It says the knot makes the Alpha and Omega bond stronger and pregnancy is likely..

It’s a good thing I took the after pill to prevent such an unplanned incident... otherwise, I would be totally ruined right now.

Angel rested her elbow on the steering wheel, turning her full body toward me in the driver’s seat. The atmosphere in the car changed completely, getting heavy, thick, and suffocatingly hot.

"So before we head home, which one do you want to taste?"

I blinked, shaking my head to clear the fog in my brain. I looked at her to confirm what she was talking about..

"Taste what?"

Angel raised three fingers, counting them off slowly with a dark, heavy look in her eyes.

"I have tasted your pussy and your titties.. hmm, not your lips... so which one of me do you want to taste... my dragon ball, my boobs, or my lips..."

I stared at her, my tongue glued to the roof of my mouth. Was she being serious? Right here in the dark parking lot?

"Just drive, I’m not doing any of that." I squeezed my knees tightly together, my voice coming out small and breathless.

It was a total lie. The heat inside me was hammering against my chest, making my skin itch and my mouth go dry. I wanted to taste all of them so badly but... no way... I couldn’t give her that power over me.

Just when I thought Angel was going to give up, turn the key, and start the engine, she reached down. In one smooth motion, She touch her shirt and stripped it off, throwing it into the back seat. Then she unbuttoned her pants, pushing the heavy fabric down her hips and bringing out her dick from inside..

My throat caught. My eyes dilated, locked onto her bare chest and the thick warmth suddenly filling the air between us.

"Tick tock.. tick tock... tick tock.... Choose only one.. you may never have an opportunity like this...." Angel taunted, her voice sounding like a hypnotic spell in the small, dark space of the car.

I kept staring at her as she talked, my mind and body being completely controlled by my Omega biology...

The sweet, heavy scent of her Alpha pheromones filled the enclosed car, washing over my senses until my thoughts completely scattered.

My hands shook on my lap.

"My lips, my titties, or my dragon ball, the choice is yours, babygirl....."

My eyes flicked back and forth. I have tasted the lips.

So it’s either the boobs or the dick..

My heart pounded like a war drum against my ribs. My instincts took over completely, washing away every last bit of my sanity and pride.

Without thinking straight, my mouth went straight to Angel Morningstar’s nipple..